ASUENE Blog

Article Details

Ninth Circuit Ruling on SB 253 and SB 261: Scope 1 and 2 Proceed, Scope 3 and SB 261 Likely Unconstitutional

GHG Protocol Large Enterprise Regulation Scope1 Scope2 Scope3 US
Ninth Circuit Ruling on SB 253 and SB 261: Scope 1 and 2 Proceed, Scope 3 and SB 261 Likely Unconstitutional
Article Summary

Introduction

On November 9, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit allowed California’s SB 253 Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions reporting to proceed. The court found that SB 253’s Scope 3 reporting requirement and SB 261’s climate-related financial risk reporting likely violate the First Amendment. It sent the question of whether Scope 3 can be severed from the rest of SB 253 back to the district court.

For executives, the ruling splits California’s climate disclosure regime into separate tracks. Scope 1 and Scope 2 carbon accounting is enforceable now. The future of Scope 3 and climate risk disclosure in California depends on further litigation and on CARB’s rulemaking for 2027 and later years.

Key Takeaways

  • SB 253 Scope 1 and Scope 2 reporting remains enforceable, and the California Air Resources Board (CARB) continues its rulemaking for reporting in 2027 and later years.
  • Whether SB 253 survives as a whole depends on the district court’s ruling on whether the Scope 3 requirement is severable.
  • SB 261 is likely unconstitutional in its entirety and has been enjoined pending appeal since November 18, 2025.
  • The decision is a preliminary-injunction ruling by a divided panel, and the Ninth Circuit precedent behind the Scope 1 and 2 holding faces a pending petition at the U.S. Supreme Court.

What Did the Ninth Circuit Decide in U.S. Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez?

On November 9, 2026, a divided Ninth Circuit panel allowed SB 253 Scope 1 and 2 reporting to proceed, found Scope 3 reporting and SB 261 likely unconstitutional under the First Amendment, and remanded the Scope 3 severability question to the district court. The ruling addresses a preliminary injunction, not the final merits.

Judge Jacqueline H. Nguyen wrote the majority opinion. Judge Mark J. Bennett concurred in the judgment in part and dissented in part, and would have enjoined both laws in full.

Ruling at a Glance

Ninth Circuit Outcome by Provision

Ninth Circuit outcome and practical meaning for SB 253 Scope 1 and Scope 2, SB 253 Scope 3, and SB 261
Provision Ninth Circuit outcome What it means
SB 253 Scope 1 and Scope 2 Affirmed denial of preliminary injunction Remains in effect; depends on severability ruling
SB 253 Scope 3 Reversed denial of preliminary injunction; remanded to determine severability Likely unconstitutional; severability pending
SB 261 Reversed denial of preliminary injunction (in its entirety) Likely unconstitutional; enjoined pending appeal since November 18, 2025

Source: U.S. Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez, No. 25-5327 (9th Cir. Nov. 9, 2026).

Is the ruling final? No. The court reviewed only the denial of a preliminary injunction, so it assessed which provisions are likely unconstitutional. Further proceedings will decide the merits.

California SB 253 and SB 261 Requirements: Scope, Thresholds, and Penalties

SB 253 requires entities doing business in California with more than $1 billion in annual revenue to disclose greenhouse gas emissions annually under the GHG Protocol, with penalties up to $500,000 per reporting year. SB 261 requires companies above $500 million in revenue to publish biennial climate-related financial risk reports.

SB 253 uses the GHG Protocol definitions. Scope 1 covers direct emissions from owned or controlled sources, Scope 2 covers purchased energy, and Scope 3 covers upstream and downstream value chain emissions. The law requires third-party assurance and public disclosure through a CARB platform, and covers an estimated 1,971 companies.

SB 261 covers an estimated 2,675 companies. Reports follow the June 2017 TCFD framework of governance, strategy, risk management, and metrics and targets, with strategy and metrics disclosures subject to a materiality test.

Why Did Scope 1 and 2 Reporting Survive While Scope 3 Did Not?

The court treated Scope 1 and 2 data as factual information drawn from a company’s own records and relevant to investors, which places it within commercial speech. Scope 3 data originates with suppliers and customers the company does not control, so the court applied strict scrutiny and found the requirement likely fails.

Scope 1 and 2: Commercial Speech Tied to Capital Markets

The court reasoned that emissions disclosures work like product warnings for investors, since higher emissions may signal lower returns. It accepted the State’s interests in reducing information asymmetries and emissions, citing a study that documented emissions reductions of approximately 7 to 8% under mandatory Scope 1 and 2 reporting. It rejected the State’s greenwashing interest as unsupported by the record.

Scope 3: Third-Party Data That Fails Strict Scrutiny

Why is Scope 3 treated differently? According to the Ninth Circuit, Scope 3 disclosures concern diffuse third-party conduct across the value chain, which is insufficiently tethered to the company’s own operations and capital transactions to qualify as commercial speech. Under strict scrutiny it failed on three points: companies must rely on partner data or industry-average estimates, the link between Scope 3 data and investor decisions was too remote, and no study in the record examined mandatory Scope 3 reporting.

Why Did the Court Find SB 261 Climate Risk Reporting Likely Unconstitutional?

SB 261 incorporates the TCFD Framework, which requires governance, strategy, risk management, and metrics disclosures. The court held that these disclosures compel predictive and normative judgments on a politically contested subject, making them noncommercial speech. Applying strict scrutiny, the court found that less restrictive alternatives were available to the State.

The majority said SB 261 requires companies to forecast uncertain future conditions and judge whether mitigating climate risk is worth the cost, within a framework the State prescribes. Even assuming compelling interests, the State could have publicized existing voluntary disclosures or incentivized voluntary reporting instead.

Judge Bennett went further, arguing that both SB 253 and SB 261 compel noncommercial speech and should be enjoined.

What Happens Next for SB 253 and Scope 3 Reporting?

SB 253 Scope 1 and 2 reporting continues, but the law’s future turns on the district court’s severability ruling. If Scope 3 is severed, Scope 1 and 2 obligations would stand on their own. If not, the court noted the Scope 3 defect would affect every application of SB 253.

Timeline

What Comes Next for SB 253 and SB 261

The July 21, 2026 CARB items are staff proposals, not adopted rules.

Timeline of key milestones and pending decisions for SB 253 and SB 261 by status, date and event
Status Date Event
Happened November 18, 2025 Ninth Circuit enjoins SB 261 pending appeal
Happened July 21, 2026 CARB staff propose 2027 rules: five Scope 3 categories and limited assurance of Scope 1 and 2
Happened November 9, 2026 Ninth Circuit ruling: Scope 1 and 2 proceed; Scope 3 and SB 261 likely unconstitutional
Pending To be determined District court ruling on Scope 3 severability
Pending To be determined CARB final rules for 2027 reporting
Pending To be determined Supreme Court action on the Stolfi petition (No. 25-1018)

Sources: Ninth Circuit opinion (No. 25-5327); CARB SB 253 Public Workshop (July 21, 2026); CARB 2026 Reporting Guidance; Supreme Court clerk’s notice (No. 25-1018).

The ruling did not affect the first Scope 1 and 2 reporting cycle, which was due November 10, 2026. Three factors will shape what follows:

  • Severability: the district court will decide whether Scope 3 can be separated under section 38532(i). The Ninth Circuit set no timeline for that ruling.
  • CARB’s 2027 rules: in July 2026, CARB staff proposed phasing in Scope 3 across five categories from 2027 and requiring limited assurance of Scope 1 and 2 from 2027. These proposals now face legal uncertainty.
  • Supreme Court review: the majority relied heavily on Stolfi, a Ninth Circuit precedent now captioned PhRMA v. O’Day at the Supreme Court. The certiorari petition was filed on February 20, 2026, docketed on February 24, 2026 as No. 25-1018, and is listed as pending.

What Happens Next for SB 261 Climate Risk Reporting?

SB 261 has been enjoined pending appeal since November 18, 2025, and the Ninth Circuit has now reversed the denial of a preliminary injunction for the law in its entirety. Its ultimate fate depends on further proceedings. Companies with $500 million to $1 billion in revenue, covered only by SB 261, currently face no enforceable obligation under California’s two climate disclosure laws.

Companies above $1 billion in revenue are relieved of the TCFD-based report for now but keep SB 253 Scope 1 and 2 reporting. In our analysis, any future California climate risk mandate would need to address the court’s tailoring concerns.

Two questions remain open as of publication: whether CARB will set an alternative SB 261 reporting date, and whether either party will seek further review of the Ninth Circuit’s decision.

How Should Executives Prepare for SB 253 Reporting in 2027 and Beyond?

With CARB’s second rulemaking underway and Scope 3 severability unresolved, executives face a two-track planning horizon. The priority is strengthening Scope 1 and 2 data quality and readiness for third-party assurance, while maintaining Scope 3 measurement capability so the company can respond quickly once courts and CARB clarify the requirement.

The following is our strategic guidance, not legal advice:

  1. Treat Scope 1 and 2 as compliance-grade data, built from financial accounts, fixed asset records, lease listings, and utility invoices.
  2. Prepare for assurance. SB 253 requires third-party assurance and authorizes penalties of up to $500,000 per reporting year.
  3. Keep Scope 3 ready for the five categories CARB staff proposed: purchased goods and services, fuel and energy related activities, waste generated during operations, business travel, and employee commuting.
  4. Monitor three triggers: the severability ruling, CARB’s final 2027 rules, and the Stolfi petition.

Conclusion: Building a Defensible Carbon Accounting Foundation

The Ninth Circuit’s ruling leaves Scope 1 and 2 reporting enforceable in California for now, while leaving Scope 3 and climate risk disclosure in legal uncertainty. Executives who strengthen operational emissions data now, and keep value chain measurement ready, will be positioned for any outcome of the remand and CARB’s 2027 rulemaking.

Waiting for final rulings risks compressing data collection and assurance preparation into a short window. The opinion also notes that 82% of North American companies in the State’s dataset have made public pledges to reduce emissions with at least one emissions target. In our analysis, the same measurement work also supports Net Zero and other corporate targets.

ASUENE provides carbon accounting solutions, including ASUENE SUPPLY CHAIN for supply chain emissions, to help executive teams prepare for this transition.

  • Initiate a board-level review of SB 253 exposure and 2027 readiness.
  • Deploy carbon accounting that produces assurance-ready Scope 1 and 2 data.
  • Implement Scope 3 measurement for CARB’s five proposed categories.

Contact ASUENE to start your SB 253 readiness assessment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is SB 253 still in effect after the Ninth Circuit ruling? +

Yes, for Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the denial of a preliminary injunction for those requirements, so they remain enforceable for now, although their status depends on the severability ruling. The Scope 3 requirement was found likely unconstitutional, and its severability is pending in the district court.

Do companies still have to report Scope 3 emissions in California? +

Scope 3 reporting was scheduled to begin in 2027 under CARB’s timeline, and the Ninth Circuit found the requirement likely violates the First Amendment. Whether it survives depends on the district court’s severability ruling and CARB’s 2027 rules. Companies should maintain Scope 3 measurement readiness until those questions are resolved.

What happens if the district court finds Scope 3 is not severable? +

The Ninth Circuit stated that, absent severance, the Scope 3 defect would exist in every application of SB 253. In our analysis, SB 253 as a whole, including Scope 1 and 2 reporting, would then be at risk of being enjoined. If Scope 3 is severed, Scope 1 and 2 reporting continues independently.

Is SB 261 struck down? +

Not finally. The Ninth Circuit held that SB 261 likely violates the First Amendment in its entirety and reversed the denial of a preliminary injunction. Enforcement has been enjoined pending appeal since November 18, 2025, but a final ruling on the merits requires further proceedings.

Why did the court treat Scope 3 differently from Scope 1 and 2? +

The court found that Scope 1 and 2 data comes from a company’s own operations and records and bears on capital transactions, which makes it commercial speech. Scope 3 disclosures concern diffuse third-party conduct across the value chain, insufficiently tethered to the company’s own operations and capital transactions. The court held they are not commercial speech and likely fail strict scrutiny.

Does the ruling affect CARB’s rulemaking for 2027? +

CARB is running a second rulemaking for 2027 and later years, and in July 2026 its staff proposed phased Scope 3 reporting across five categories. The ruling places those Scope 3 proposals under legal uncertainty. How CARB will adjust those proposals remains open as of publication.

Which companies are covered by SB 253 and SB 261? +

SB 253 covers entities doing business in California with more than $1 billion in annual revenue, an estimated 1,971 companies. SB 261 covers companies doing business in California with more than $500 million in annual revenue, an estimated 2,675 companies.

Sources

References

  1. U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit: “U.S. Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez, No. 25-5327”, opinion filed November 9, 2026
  2. California Air Resources Board: “California Corporate Greenhouse Gas Reporting: Guidance for SB 253 2026 Reporting Submittals”, September 1, 2026
  3. California Air Resources Board: “SB 253 Public Workshop: California Corporate Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program”, July 21, 2026
  4. California Air Resources Board: “Climate-Related Financial Risk Reports (SB 261) Docket”
  5. Supreme Court of the United States, Office of the Clerk: “Notice of docketing, Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America v. O’Day, No. 25-1018”, February 24, 2026

Why Work with ASUENE Inc.?

ASUENE is a key player in carbon accounting, offering a comprehensive platform that measures, reduces, and reports emissions, including Scope 1-3. ASUENE serves over 56,000 clients worldwide, providing an all-in-one solution that integrates GHG accounting, ESG supply chain management, a Carbon Credit exchange platform, and third-party verification.

ASUENE supports companies in achieving net-zero goals through advanced technology, consulting services, and an extensive network.

Contact Us!

Latest Article List

Related Articles

Accelerate Your Path to Net Zero.

Every organization's journey is unique.
We'll build a solution around yours.